Where to get Peanut Butter Pie ice cream in NJ
19 stands we've found serving Peanut Butter Pie ice cream, by county.
Cape May County (5)
- Hobby Horse Ice Cream Parlor & Cafe · Ocean City
- Marita's Homemade Ice Cream · Sea Isle City
- Nana and Poppy's Ice cream Parlor · Sea Isle City
- Happy's Ice Cream · Wildwood Crest
- Jurassic Swirled (at Jurassic Adventure Golf) · North Wildwood
Monmouth County (4)
- Jersey Freeze · Freehold
- Days Ice Cream · Ocean Grove
- Jersey Freeze · Colts Neck
- Jersey Freeze - Bell Labs · Holmdel
Other (3)
- Gil & Bert's Ice Cream · Cranbury
- Sprinklz · West Berlin
- LICK · Swedesboro
Ocean County (1)
- Skipper Dipper · Long Beach
Bergen County (1)
- Ernie's Ice Cream · Mahwah
Passaic County (1)
- Falls Creamery · Little Falls Township
Morris County (1)
- Scoops · Chatham
Gloucester County (1)
- Bears Country Custard · Williamstown
Union County (1)
- Rocko's Ice Cream · Fanwood
Middlesex County (1)
- Frozen Flamingo · Carteret
Flavors change often and vary by day. Spotted Peanut Butter Pie somewhere we missed?