✓ Water ice confirmed Custard Castle
137 US-9, Marmora, NJ 08223, USA
Calls it water ice ★ 4.5 (117)
Prices
Small · $3.70 · Jul 2026 Medium · $4.65 · Jul 2026 Large · $5.50 · Jul 2026
Newest price we have for each size, with the month it was observed (from menu-board photos and 2026 phone calls). May vary by location.
Water ice flavors (10)
Cotton CandyMangoCherryChocolateRoot BeerLemonStrawberry LemonadeMoundWater IceGelati
Also scoops ice cream (58 flavors)
ChocolateCookies N'CreamMint Chocolate ChipPurple CowCookie DoughCaramel TurtleCoffee Midnight EspressoBananaButter PecanStrawberryPeanut Butter CupSalted Caramel PretzelDeath By ChocolateCake BatterCookies N' CreamCaramel SwirlMoundzBlueberryDouble BrownieSalted CaramelWet WalnutMarshmallowCreamsicleChocolate ChipsHot FudgeCookies + CreamBrownieOreoGummi BearsPeanutsHeath BarVanillaM&MButterscotchBirthday CakeSnickersCookies & CreamOreo MintPineapplePeanut Butter
+ 18 more
Also on the menu
Water IceHand Dipped Ice CreamSoft ServeFrozen CustardIce Cream SandwichesGelatiShakesFloatsConesHand DippedSundaesCastle SwirlHomemade Fudge SundaesNoveltieshard ice cream
Good to know
Walk-up windowParking lot🐾 Dog-friendlyDairy-free options
From stand photos. Double-check before a special trip.
More photos
