Custard Corral

2100 E Broad St, Millville, NJ 08332, USA

★ 4.5 (472)

Trending ice cream shop with goats and a merry-go-round, plus grilled cheese sandwiches, and play equipment. — summary via Google

Prices

Small · $3.50 · Jul 2026 Medium · $4.50 · Jul 2026 Large · $5.50 · Jul 2026 Quart · $6.00 · Jul 2026

Newest price we have for each size, with the month it was observed (from menu-board photos and 2026 phone calls). May vary by location.

Water ice flavors (36)

StrawberryOrangeBlueberryRaspberryLemon-LimeCherryBlue RaspberryBananaPineappleMangoTropical RainbowCotton CandyCandy FishBanana SlicesNutter ButterCrushed CherryM&M'SGummy Worms/BearsButterscotchPeanutsChocolate SyrupDry WalnutsChocolate ChipsAlmondsMarshmallowReese'S Cups/PiecesChocolate Chip CookiesWhole CherriesButter FingerHeathKrunch KoteStrawberry ShortcakeWatermelonGrapeRoot BeerRootbeer

Seasonal / limited-time

Peach CobblerHawaiian Delight

Also scoops ice cream (34 flavors)

Mint Chocolate ChipVanillaChocolateCoffeeDouble Mint FudgeBrowniesOreoMaltBanana BreadPeanut Butter Fudge FluffOrange And Vanilla Twist CustardBananaBrownieStrawberryHot Fudge Peanut BitsCaramelPineappleMarshmallow SauceBlack & WhitePeanut ButterPeanut Butter SaucePiñA ColadaDiptopWet WalnutsBlueberriesApplesCakePretzelWaffleJimmiesRainbow JimmiesHot FudgeShort BreadPina Colada

Also on the menu

SlushSmoothieFrozen CustardHard Ice CreamSundaesConcretesMilkshakesHot DogsFried Itemsice creamgrilled cheese sandwichescaketoppingshand-dipped flavorsStrawberry