Jimmy's Ice Cream

525 Milford Warren Glen Rd, Milford, NJ 08848, USA

Calls it water ice & Italian ice ★ 4.8 (573)

Stream-side ice cream stand offering soft-serve classics, sandwiches, mini golf and more. — summary via Google

Prices

Pint · $4.75 · Aug 2021 Quart · $6.12 · Aug 2021

Newest price we have for each size, with the month it was observed (from menu-board photos and 2026 phone calls). May vary by location.

These prices are from 2021. Know the 2026 price?

Snap the menu board or type in what a medium costs. Takes 20 seconds and keeps the index honest.

Water ice flavors (45)

Black RaspberryPistachioMocha CappuccinoWatermelonMangoBubblegumCookie CollisionButterscotchPunchLemonCherry Water IcePeachBlackberryCucumber MelonPistachio Cookie CollisionPearGrapeKiwiWatermelon-ChipIced TeaMojitoPapayaSangriaChocolate Peanut ButterHoneydewMintMelon ChipMargaritaCantaloupePeanut Butter-OreoLemonadeDaiquiriGuavaPineappleCoconutPiñA ColadaCherryBlue Cotton CandyPassion FruitLimeRaspberryCookies & CreamUSA PistachioAlmond JoyOrange

Seasonal / limited-time

Flavor Of The WeekPumpkin SpiceHomemade Cookie CakeHomemade Peanut Butter CookieExtra CakeEggnogCranberryPeppermintApple CinnamonGingerbreadBlue-Cotton CandyHomemade Raisin FudgeIce Cream CakeCandy CaneSherbet

Also scoops ice cream (118 flavors)

Hard Ice CreamHomemade SherbetFlavor BurstCheesecakeStrawberryCotton CandyBanana RippleTropical OrangeBlue GooPeanut Butter SundaeCookies-N-CreamBirthday CakeBananaVanillaChocolateCoffeePeanut ButterBlueberryBUTTERFINGERHot FudgeCaramelJava ChunkWarm BrownieFluffer NutterDreamciclePeanut CrunchBUTTER PECANHeath BarN.S.A.RedMango LemonFudgeDusty RoadFruity PebblesM&MsOreoCookie DoughBlack Raspberry-ChipPink StarburstPeanut Butter Blast

+ 78 more

Also on the menu

Water IceHard Ice CreamHomemade SherbetSoft Serve Ice CreamConesCupsWaffle ConesHard ShellSprinklesFlavor BurstSundaesFluffer NutterBanana SplitBrownieOreo Mint