Pennsville Custard Stand

338 N Broadway, Pennsville, NJ 08070, USA

Calls it water ice ★ 4.8 (532)

Prices

Water ice · $3.25

From photos, calls, and visitor reports. May be out of date or vary by location.

We don't have a recent price here. Know the 2026 price?

Snap the menu board or type in what a medium costs. Takes 20 seconds and keeps the index honest.

Water ice flavors (21)

Blue RaspberryCherryGreen AppleMangoRubeHerbalVANILLABlue & GoldCHERRY BANANAPistachioBANANARainbowPatrioticMONSTERWALNUTCHARM PRETZELChoc StrawbStrawberryCotton CandyPeanut ButterIcy Nutella

Seasonal / limited-time

Cinnamon Sugar CookieStrawberry Monkey BusinessNSA VanillaNSA BananaApple PieCaramel CoffeeSweet & Salty Caramel Pretzel

Also scoops ice cream (156 flavors)

Jersey PeachHomemade Ice CreamWater IceBlue & GoldRainbowChocolatePatrioticNJ Peach Ice CreamCherryPineappleWalnutPeanut ButterBananaMintsNutellaReese'S CupReese'S PiecesPretzelsCoconutButterfingerMaltVanillaMint ChipCherry VanillaCoffeeButter PecanSpice N LemonsApple PiePistachioRum RaisinBea VanillaBea Mint ChipBea BananaChocolate Fudge BrownieChocolate Peanut ButterCookie MonsterSweet&Salty Carb PretzelSouthern PecanHoney BusinessCherry Cheesecake

+ 116 more

Also on the menu

Frozen CustardIce Cream SandwichesChocolate Dipped BananasIce Cream NachosHand Dipped Hot Fudge Ice CreamArctic SwirlsHot DogsSoft PretzelsSoft DrinksSundaesBanana Splitscustardwater icesundaesshakes